We compared Polka, Tjhoko and RustOleum to see which performs best for a modern kitchen revamp
Painting melamine cupboards is not always simple. The surface is slick and resistant, so only a few paints can truly hold and last. We decided to find out which ones do by testing Polka Paint in Duck Egg, Tjhoko Paint in Magical Marina and RustOleum Painters Touch Plus Satin Spray in Olive Green on real melamine cupboard doors.
We went out and found 3 different styles of melamine cupboard doors that we can use for this makeover. Each door was cleaned with a degreaser, lightly sanded and painted according to each brand’s guidelines. We applied two coats of paint and a clear protective layer where needed. Our focus was on coverage, texture, ease of use and overall appearance after drying.
Tjhoko Paint Magical Marina
Tjhoko Paint is a South African favourite for creative furniture and decorative projects. Magical Marina is a soft, cool green that adds a charming touch to any space. The paint is water-based and non-toxic, with a “built-in” primer and sealer, which makes it appealing for quick updates and family-safe projects.
Benefits
-
Easy to apply with minimal preparation
-
Low odour and environmentally friendly
-
Creates a soft matte chalk look with rich colour
Drawbacks
-
Needs careful sealing for extra durability in busy kitchens
-
Slightly longer drying and curing time
-
May require additional coats for perfect coverage on darker surfaces
Tjhoko Paint works beautifully on accent doors or feature pieces. It gives a homely, handcrafted look that suits rustic and cottage-style kitchens, provided it receives proper finishing for lasting protection.
Polka Paint Duck Egg
Polka Paint impressed us from the very start. The Duck Egg shade is an elegant and soothing green that is applied evenly with almost no visible brush lines. The paint has a self-levelling formula that allows it to smooth out as it dries, producing a refined, even finish. Polka Paint also includes a “built-in” sealer, making it a genuine no-fuss option for anyone wanting lasting results with minimal effort.
Benefits
-
Self-levelling formula ensures a smooth, brush-free finish
-
Built-in sealer adds durability without extra steps
-
Strong pigmentation provides excellent coverage
-
Water-based, eco-friendly and low odour
-
Adheres exceptionally well to melamine and similar surfaces
Drawbacks
-
Works best with light sanding and proper surface cleaning
-
Requires steady layering for the most even finish
We found Polka Paint to be the easiest to use and the most rewarding in appearance. It dries quickly, feels smooth to the touch and delivers a consistent professional look. The colour remains vibrant, and the finish holds up well in a typical kitchen setting. For its balance of performance, simplicity and environmental responsibility, Polka Paint was the clear standout.
RustOleum Painters Touch Plus Satin Spray Olive Green
RustOleum has long been trusted for its quick-drying spray paints that deliver a durable, factory-like finish. The Olive Green satin tone gave a modern, stylish result that felt solid and smooth once cured. The aerosol format makes it a convenient choice for smaller projects or single-feature doors.
Benefits
-
Fast application with a smooth satin finish
-
Quick drying and durable
-
Ideal for smaller surfaces or accent areas
Drawbacks
-
Overspray can be messy without proper preparation
-
Coverage is limited for large projects
-
Requires ventilation and masking during use
- Gave a slightly glossy look upon drying. (We aimed for a matte finish.)
RustOleum is best suited for those who want a speedy update with a sleek finish. It provides excellent durability on smaller pieces and works well for accent cabinetry or trims.
Our Final Verdict
After testing all three paints, Polka Paint in Duck Egg clearly stood out as the best performer. It offered exceptional coverage, a beautifully smooth finish, and an effortless painting experience. The “built-in” sealer makes it a practical and time-saving choice, and its eco-friendly formula adds extra appeal for homeowners who care about safer products.
For South Africans looking to update their melamine cupboards with a professional result, Polka Paint is the product we would confidently recommend. It combines quality, durability and ease of use in one impressive tin, making it an ideal choice for any modern kitchen revamp.
